A Florida city councilwoman suspended after a decade of racist and anti-LGBTQ+ social media posts surfaced is now suing the very council that punished her, arguing it never had the authority to act at all.
A decade of ugly posts, finally confronted
Judi Fike was appointed to the Groveland City Council in October 2024 and was running for a full term when the Orlando Sentinel published years of her old social media activity. The posts, some dating back to at least 2015, target both Black people and LGBTQ+ people with slurs and mockery. One image compared President Barack Obama to a primate. Others fixated on the word "thug," with Fike writing in 2015 that it was "the new n word" and, in 2019, that "thug life = thug treatment = no pity from me."
The most shocking post came just hours after the 2016 Pulse nightclub shooting in nearby Orlando, when Fike wrote on Facebook: "Duh….why would the shooter target a gay club? My answer…Easier than marching them up steps to push off the roof..some sarcasm, some truth…" In 2015 she'd also dismissed the "#LGBT freak show" as having "had its run."
This is a picture of President Ronald Reagan babysitting Barack Obama, except it is an ape, a baboon, a monkey or whatever you call it.
Barbara Gaines, Groveland Vice Mayor
Denial, an apology, and a lawsuit
Confronted with screenshots at a public meeting, Fike offered a partial apology "to anyone who was hurt" while insisting the timing amounted to a political hit job. "I will not let that tactic work," she said. On the Pulse post specifically, she claimed she'd actually been referencing reports of a Middle Eastern group pushing gay people off buildings, saying it "might have been written in poor taste" but was "meant as a support of the community, not against the community." On other posts, she denied authorship outright, calling them "manipulated" and insisting "those are not my words."
The council wasn't persuaded and voted to suspend her pending an investigation. Groveland Mayor Kevin Keogh said his bigger concern was Fike's credibility, not just the old posts: "It has to do with the non-truthful nature of your response." Two days later, Fike filed suit. Her attorney, Lake County Commissioner and two-time congressional candidate Anthony Sabatini, argues the council overstepped: "The city does not have the legal authority to suspend or remove any of its members, period. It just simply does not have that authority. Most cities don't." That's a genuinely contested legal question; many Florida municipalities, including Groveland, rely on a signed code of ethics to justify suspending members pending investigation, and the city is expected to lean on that authority in its defense.
A town with its own reckoning
Groveland's history makes the racism allegations land differently. In 1949, false rape accusations against four Black teenagers, known as the Groveland Four, led to the lynching of two of them and the wrongful imprisonment of the others. They weren't posthumously pardoned until 2019. For a council in that town to be publicly airing images comparing a Black president to an animal is not an abstract controversy; it's a town confronting its own past in real time.
MQ's Take
What stands out isn't just that Fike posted this stuff, it's the shape of her defense afterward: deny some of it outright, recast the rest as misunderstood support, then frame accountability itself as the real offense. That's a familiar script for officials caught with a paper trail, and bringing in an attorney with his own history of anti-LGBTQ+ legislative pushes doesn't read as coincidence. Whether or not the lawsuit succeeds on the narrow question of council authority, Groveland's LGBTQ+ and Black residents are left with a representative who joked about their community dying, and a legal fight aimed less at clearing her name than at making the suspension itself disappear.
Source: LGBTQ Nation
Cover photo: Christian Wasserfallen / Pexels
