Skip to main content
Shop
New Arrivals
Best Sellers
On Sale
Sex Toys
Vibrators
Dildos
Anal Toys
Masturbators
Cock Rings
View All →
For Her
Vibrators
Clitoral
G-Spot
Bullets & Eggs
Rabbit Style
View All →
For Him
Masturbators
Cock Rings
Penis Pumps
Prostate
Extensions
View All →
Bondage & Fetish
Restraints
Cuffs
Whips & Paddles
Nipple Play
Bondage Kits
View All →
Lubricants
Water-Based
Silicone-Based
Anal Lubes
Flavored
Massage
View All →
Lingerie
Stockings
Women's
Men's
Costumes
View All →
For Couples
Couples Toys
Sensual Kits
Games
View All →
Essentials
Condoms
Hygiene
Wellness
View All →
Shop All Products
Guides
Topics
LGBTQ+ News
Sex & Intimacy
Relationships
Health & Wellness
Product Guides
View All →
Popular Guides
Beginner's Guide to Toys
Lube Guide
Couples Play
View All →
Help
FAQ
Common questions
Shipping & Returns
Delivery info
Contact Us
Get in touch
Order Tracking
Track your order
About
en
Menu
Sign in
Create account
Shop
Guides
Help
About
Quick Actions
Wishlist
Dark Mode
Home
/
Shop
/
Anal Toys
/
Small & Medium Butt Plugs
Small & Medium Butt Plugs
All Small & Medium Butt Plugs
1,334 products available
‹
Previous
1
…
51
52
53
…
56
Next
›
Filters
Sort:
Newest
Active filters:
Category: Small & Medium Butt Plugs
Clear all
OUT OF STOCK
A-Play Groovy. Silicone Anal Plug Sunrise
$57.97
Out of Stock
11% OFF
OUT OF STOCK
Whipsmart Heartbreaker Metal Plug Md
$53.97
$60.97
Out of Stock
OUT OF STOCK
Shots Ouch! Round Gem Butt Plug Large Gold/emerald
$16.97 - $23.97
Out of Stock
10% OFF
OUT OF STOCK
665 Stretch'r Tripole Butt Plug - M Black Metallic
$156.97
$174.97
Out of Stock
10% OFF
OUT OF STOCK
665 Stretch'r Tripole Butt Plug - M Gun Metal
$156.97
$174.97
Out of Stock
11% OFF
OUT OF STOCK
665 Stretch'r Sirup Butt Plug - M Black Metallic
$159.97
$178.97
Out of Stock
10% OFF
OUT OF STOCK
665 Stretch'r Sirup Butt Plug - L Gun Metal
$218.97
$243.97
Out of Stock
10% OFF
OUT OF STOCK
665 Stretch'r Ripple Butt Plug - L Black Metallic
$180.97
$201.97
Out of Stock
11% OFF
OUT OF STOCK
665 Stretch'r Scaly Butt Plug - M Gun Metal
$143.97
$160.97
Out of Stock
11% OFF
OUT OF STOCK
Ass-Sation Remote Vibrating Metal Anal Lover Silver
$128.97
$144.97
Out of Stock
10% OFF
OUT OF STOCK
Doxy Ribbed Metal Butt Plug
$62.97
$69.97
Out of Stock
10% OFF
OUT OF STOCK
Bootie M Black
$69.97
$77.97
Out of Stock
11% OFF
OUT OF STOCK
Satisfyer Power Plug Black
$72.97
$81.97
Out of Stock
12% OFF
OUT OF STOCK
Satisfyer Double Ball R Dk Blue
$29.77
$33.97
Out of Stock
10% OFF
OUT OF STOCK
Snuggy Flapping Anal Plug Vibrator- Black
$117.77
$130.97
Out of Stock
13% OFF
OUT OF STOCK
Jelly Caribbean 6 w/ P Purple
$20.97
$23.97
Out of Stock
11% OFF
OUT OF STOCK
Pink Holic Curved Remote Vibrating Anal Plug
$80.97
$90.97
Out of Stock
11% OFF
OUT OF STOCK
Rose Twister Hands-Free Remote Vibrating Anal Plug
$86.97
$97.97
Out of Stock
13% OFF
OUT OF STOCK
Hello Sexy! Booty Cutie - Lilac
$20.97
$23.97
Out of Stock
10% OFF
OUT OF STOCK
Sport Fucker Scrum Plug Ruck - Blue
$52.87
$58.97
Out of Stock
10% OFF
OUT OF STOCK
Thunder P Rim Slide Black
$220.97
$245.97
Out of Stock
11% OFF
OUT OF STOCK
Loveline Jubilee 10 Speed Vibe Silicone Rechargeable Waterproof Pink
$78.97
$88.97
Out of Stock
11% OFF
OUT OF STOCK
Bootie L Black
$58.97
$65.97
Out of Stock
11% OFF
OUT OF STOCK
Blue Line Medium Tapered Plug 5 Blu
$31.97
$35.97
Out of Stock
Load More Products
